painting of men rowing a boat
Pull for Shore, painting by John George Brown, 1878. (Wikimedia Commons)

Thoughts and Prayers

Don't be confused about the function of Jewish prayer.

“Our thoughts and prayers are with you.” What can this mean in the wake of something horrible? If prayer is a way of changing the world, it is too late. What good can prayers do the victims now?

The 17th-century rabbi, Leon de Modena asked us to imagine watching a man pull his boat to shore. If you were confused, you might think that he was really pulling the shore to his boat. People have much the same confusion about prayer: Some believe that you are pulling God closer to you. But in fact heartfelt prayer pulls you closer to God.

Seen this way, prayer is a sturdy rope of solidarity, one that acknowledges that we are in this together. In a free society when something terrible occurs, as Abraham Joshua Heschel taught, few are guilty but all are responsible. Prayer says: “I am with you. I might have done more. Your pain is not separate from my deeds and my life. I pray that you will have comfort, and that I, along with others who know of your suffering, will work to make a world in which such pain is banished.”

Rabbi David Wolpe’s musings are shared in My Jewish Learning’s Shabbat newsletter, Recharge, a weekly collection of readings to refresh your soul. Sign up to receive the newsletter.

Discover More

Bad Preaching

A great sermon is a collaboration between speaker and listener.

The Prayer of Natural Beauty

Judaism contains blessings for seeing beautiful mountains, the ocean, a rainbow, and other natural sights.

Hatred’s Door

Are we numb to the rise in global antisemitism?