Herring in an Overcoat (Herring Pie)

A resourceful and flavorful herring dish, straight from the shtetl.

This is another moment of shtetl brilliance. Amidst severe poverty, this festive-looking dish was concocted from the humblest ingredients.

For other herring variations, try these recipes for the classic herring and onions and forshmak.


lots of mayonnaise (you can use soy mayo if you're so health-conscious)

4-5 potatoes, peeled, cubed, and boiled

2 hard-boiled eggs, chopped

1 sour apple, peeled, cored, and cut into thin long pieces

3 medium onions, chopped small

1 large carrot, peeled, grated, and boiled

2 beets, peeled, grated, and boiled

2 nicely sized herrings, fillets separated


Chop the herring fillets into small pieces and arrange half of the pieces as a dense layer in a large dish, so you cannot see the dish's bottom.

Over the herring, place a layer of onions (using about half), then a layer of potatoes, then layers of carrots, apple, and beets. Spread some mayonnaise on top.

Over the beets, layer the rest of the herring, then the remaining onions, then potatoes, carrots, apple, and beets.

Finally, add a generous dallop of mayonnaise and spread it over the 'pie.' Crumble the eggs, both yolks and whites, over the top, and refrigerate before serving.

Some people have been known to add layers of walnuts and prunes, but I personally have never tried that–experiment at your own risk.

Discover More

Why the Crockpot Is Your Secret Weapon for the Summer

Cholent, Friday night chicken and weeknight favorites, all without turning on the oven.

Brisket Pad Thai Recipe

This dish hits all the right notes: sweet, savory, spicy and totally satisfying.

Falling in Love in Jerusalem

Like many great love affairs, time and the business of life eroded the fabric that bound us together.