Reprinted with permission from
,The Jewish Orthodox Feminist Alliance.
Why do “religious” men refuse to cooperate in a religious divorce? In the best of all possible worlds, we would all live happily ever after and there would be no divorce. In that world, in the rare instance that divorce became a necessity, both parties would willingly and amicably cooperate in the proceedings. But we do not live in that best of all possible worlds. Divorce is at times necessary, and at other times, desired by one party or the other. Often divorces are contested and contentious and, frequently, much time and anguish are expended on coming to terms and resolving matters in civil courts as well as in rabbinic tribunals.
The Jewish Law of a Get
Jewish law does not recognize the granting of a “no fault” divorce as a right of either the husband or the wife. In other words, just because one party wants a get does not mean that the other party must cooperate. And in most cases, a get me’useh, a compulsory divorce, is not valid. Certainly, if both parties are in agreement, a bet din will not stand in the way of their separation and will facilitate their religious divorce.
However, where only one party wants the get, Jewish law, only in rare cases, will obligate the other party to cooperate (chayav le-garesh). At other times it encourages cooperation (mitzvah legaresh). But mostly it does not grant the authority or provide the mechanism to do either.
Details of the situations in which a get can be coerced are outlined in the Shulhan Arukh, Even Ha-Ezer, chapter 154. The list includes specific circumstances in which it is either personally or religiously impossible for one party to live with the other. But the list is a limited one and does not include many of the situations confronted in our modern age. And if the situation is not found on this narrow and limited list, a beit din will refrain from coercion (ibid: 154:21).
With that as background, we return to our question: why do some “religious” men refuse to cooperate in get procedures?
Did you like this article? MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.