parashat bamidbar

A Count Of Love

The census that occurs immediately after the plague for the sin with Midian reassures the Children of Israel that they are still God's partners in the covenant.

Commentary on Parashat Pinchas, Numbers 25:10 - 30:1

After outlining the reward that Pinchas was to receive for his zealotry, God commands Moshe to attack and punish the nation of Midian for enticing the Jewish people to sin and for causing the plague that nearly consumed them. Yet, immediately following this command, the Torah abruptly changes direction, stopping in mid-sentence to begin a new count of the people.

Several questions arise from this strange turn in the text. Why does the Torah end the story of the strife with Midian so abruptly? What is the function of the new census? And why is it connected to (and then disconnected from) the story of Pinchas?

The answer to these questions lies in the curious language Moshe and Elazar utilize when initiating God’s command to count every male above age 20. Moshe and Elazar say, “Take the sum of the people from 20 years old and upward, as the Lord commanded Moshe and children of Israel who went forth from the Land of Egypt.” (26:4) After the miraculous excitement of the Exodus and the glorious revelation at Sinai, the nation of Israel suffered setbacks of ever-increasing magnitude, culminating in the punishment following the sin of the meraglim (spies), when God banished every male over age 20 from entering the Promised Land.

After 40 long years of wandering in the desert, the people were understandably full of doubt. Would God retain His relationship with them or instead move on? Would He maintain the closeness that began at Sinai or would He view the descendants of the original Am Hanivchar (chosen people) with disdain?

By counting the people anew, God aims to allay their fears and refresh their spirit by adding a sense of newness and distinction to their mission. He wishes to give them the same purity of spirit that was present in the Jewish nation after they had left Egypt. Therefore, God counts the nation again. The purpose of this count serves not as a census or military count so much as a reestablishment of their old identity as the Am Hameyuhad that would forever keep and guard God’s covenant.

The unique nature of the count becomes more apparent when we scrutinize the text of the counting itself. As opposed to the count taken at the beginning of Bamidbar, which focused on a military structure, here the count focuses on history, concentrating on the roots and families of each particular tribe and their connection to the original children of Israel. While their parents needed no family history in the earlier counting, their children, an entirely new nation, required reassurance that they indeed also constituted Klal Yisrael (congregation of Israel).

It is precisely for this reason that the Torah connects and then disconnects this counting from the plague at Shittim. After enduring the punishment of wandering in the desert for so many years, the Jews seem to immediately revert to their sinful ways when they engage the women of Midian. Had they broken the camel’s back? Had their sin pushed them over the edge, causing God to abandon them for eternity?

God immediately answers their doubts by counting them once again, “as a shepherd counts his flock.” By cherishing each member of Klal Yisrael, God reestablishes a covenant with them and ensures that they would forever be the Am Hanivhar, God’s chosen people.

Reprinted with permission from the Orthodox Union.


Discover More

Kiddushin 39

When bad things happen to good people.

What Does the Torah Say About the Land of Israel?

The entire narrative of the Hebrew Bible is built around God's promise of the land to Abraham's descendants.

Kiddushin 67

Inherited features.