Refusing to Play

This entry was posted in History on by .

Iranian-born German soccer player Ashkan Dejagah is making headlines for electing to skip his team’s upcoming match in Tel Aviv. Officially, he begged out for “personal” reasons although he has mentioned “political” reasons, as well.

The story is a significant one in Germany, a country already struggling to integrate its immigrant/minority communities. And perhaps not surprisingly, the leaders of the Jewish community have chimed in with their unambiguous critique.

The Central Council of Jews in Germany has sharply criticized the player’s stance. “It is inconceivable and impossible that a national team player initiates a private boycott of Jews,” Vice President Dieter Graumann told SPIEGEL ONLINE. Meanwhile, Central Council President Charlotte Knobloch called on the DFB to exclude Dejagah from the national team. (MORE)

The first question is, of course, does Dejagah have good reason to skip the trip to Israel? And the answer is: maybe.

The player, who still has family in Iran, told the BZ newspaper: “I have nothing against Israel. But I’m worried about having problems later when traveling to Iran.” Iran refuses to recognize Israel and forbids its citizens from visiting the country or playing in any sporting competitions with Israel.

I have no way of judging Dejagah’s sincerity, but this explanation certainly seems conceivable to me. Should he really risk never getting to see some of his family again to play a soccer match?

Additionally, let’s do a thought experiment: What would happen if a Jewish-American soccer player refused to play a match in Iran? Would the Jewish community condemn his actions? Or would he be celebrated for his loyalty to the Jewish people?

Of course, critics might respond: Israel is an open democracy; Iran is a belligerent, maverick state.

But this is a personal story here, not a diplomatic one. Dejagah is a citizen of Germany, but he is also a citizen of Iran, and he has loyalties to his home-country, as well. Iran and Israel had contentious relations before Ahmadinejad came to town, and sports has long been an arena for demonstrating patriotic sympathies.

I don’t think America had issues with specific Russian swimmers back in 1980, but we still boycotted the summer Olympics.

Bottom line: Is it possible Dejagah is initiating a “private boycott of Jews” as Dieter Graumann would have us believe? It’s possible. But that’s a pretty aggressive, condemnatory line, and with the other possible issues and questions here, I’d say it’s probably out of line.

Posted on October 10, 2007

Note: The opinions expressed here are the personal views of the author. All comments on MyJewishLearning are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed. Privacy Policy

2 thoughts on “Refusing to Play

  1. rejewvenator

    I think every person has the right to decide whether or not to travel to some other country for whatever reason. I don’t care if Dejagah’s reasons are political, personal, medical, or even hysterical in nature. He is perfectly within his rights to avoid travel to Israel.

    The question is whether such a person can still be a representative of the German National soccer team, given his restrictions. Surely, a person who could not play many games because of Sabbath observance would be a poor choice for such a team. In a different vein, a person who expressed Nazi sympathies would be a bad choice as a German representative and role model. Somewhere between these poles lies Dejagah, a man who, because he is Iranian, because he plays for Germany specifically, and because the country in question is Israel, has created a firestorm where in fact none truly existed.

    Most of the time we don’t know anything about the personal lives of the players on these national teams. No doubt, greater racism, sexism, homophobia or other prejudice exists among many players on many teams than that which may exist in Dejagah’s heart. But we don’t ask, they don’t tell, and nobody gives the matter a second thought. I would suggest that we do the same here. I don’t care if this man is on the German national team. I didn’t care last week, and I dont’ care this week. None of us will care next week. So let’s just collectively shrug our shoulders and move on.

Comments are closed.