The Red Skull Scares Me

This entry was posted in Culture, History on by .

Confession time: Captain America has never been my favorite superhero. I’m a Marvel boy, tried and true, and even though the X-Men have my heart and most perfectly embody my geekiness, the Avengers, the team that banded together around Captain America and have him as their leader (more or less), are probably my favorite superhero team.

So, as you might imagine, I’m watching the news and the previews of Captain America: The First Avenger pretty intensely.

I don’t know if you caught the Super Bowl (I didn’t) or the TV commercials (I’ve been trying to), but there was a spot for Captain America, and it’s online. It starts as standard superhero fare — there’s this kind of wimpy soldier who gets put through the ringer, an explosion or two, he get stuck into a tube and comes out all steroidy and pumped up…

And then this guy whips on screen.


The Red Skull scares me. No, more than that: He freaks the hell out of me. It’s bad enough that most supervillains have names like Doctor Doom or Darkseid and can blast nuclear endorphins out of their palms, but this guy is an actual Nazi. He shows up in comics wearing a swastika armband. He peppers his speech with references to “the annihilation” and “the future Reich.” In a few of the more noiry comics, his I’ll-get-you speeches include personal reminisces of him and Hitler.

And this is what I was reading as a ten-year-old.

The Red Skull has always been a serious character. His “skull” used to be a mask, but at some point it became his skull. More recently, he was shown (in Ultimate Avengers) giving a superhero’s wife a choice between stabbing him to death with a fork or throwing their infant child out the window. (She chose the latter. He did the former anyway.) He’s dabbled in genetic manipulation, social manipulation (he’s been elected president and been one of the richest businessmen in the United States) and mind control. He rarely just takes a gun or a bomb and blows up Fort Knox. Instead, he just messes with our heads, which is worse, or quietly plots genocides. He’s not just evil. He’s creepy.

What do you think — is the Red Skull just pushing our buttons? Or is he pushing the boundaries of what’s socially acceptable?

Posted on February 9, 2011

Note: The opinions expressed here are the personal views of the author. All comments on MyJewishLearning are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed. Privacy Policy

4 thoughts on “The Red Skull Scares Me

  1. T.C. Fedkenheuer

    I admit I don’t read graphic novels much, or keep up with the latest superheroes, but I think I’m still a pretty good judge of right and wrong. If you’re scared by the creepy guy, then the writers are doing their jobs! Perhaps because the symbols of hatred are so fresh to us, and cut so close to the bone, that they evoke a higher response in us. Pushing the limits isn’t new, nor is pushing buttons- heck, my sisters pushed my buttons a lot! My wife says, “Breathe! It’s only a movie…” As long as we hold our shields high, we have nothing to fear!

  2. Moira

    I think he even scaryer then freddy couarder.I can’t spell. What about Jason. Even i don’t know other scaryer people. I thinking. My minds gonna blunk. The red skull said it no war. I said it’s a war. Poor Cap.They better make better stories. Don’t want to scracy. That not even that scary. MAybe when i wake in the morning. I don’t want o scracy the little kids.

  3. Moira

    Dum Hitter. I hate bad guys. Red Skull. Why you keep on bugging the Cap. He doesn’t feel like a Hero. This is a song writen from .one tin soilders.They sould made better chacaters. Sf. Alien From mars.

  4. Moira

    I like to HAve a Trip to see them. Avengers. They sould Make funny comedey about the avengers. Spiderman Hulk, Giantman Wasp Other superheros that i think of. We will rock you. You rock.DD. I can’t wait till dd comes to theaters. DVD.

Comments are closed.