Reprinted with permission from
The Jewish Religion: A Companion
, published by Oxford University Press.
The first two editions of the Zohar were published in Mantua (1558-1560) and Cremona (1559-1560) [Italy]. A fierce debate took place on whether the Zohar should be printed at all, some Kabbalists arguing that it is forbidden to spread the Kabbalistic doctrines among the masses, the inevitable result of its publication in print. With the printing and subsequent wide dissemination of the Zohar, the process, beginning after the expulsion from Spain, continued of treating the Zohar as a sacred book and not only for the Kabbalists. Moralistic works quoted extensively from the Zohar. Laws and customs based on the Zohar found their way into the standard Codes, although there was much discussion on whether Zoharic practices should have the status of law. The general principle that emerged was that where the rulings found in the Zohar (and the Kabbalah generally) are in conflict with those of the Talmud and the Codes, it is the latter rulings that are binding. But where there is no conflict, the rulings found in the Zohar should be followed.
In the Christian Kabbalah and in the [false messianic] Shabbetai Zevi movement, the Zohar was set off against the Talmud, the former being held to be the true, secret meaning of religion. Naturally, this distinction was totally negated within Judaism where the idea was developed that the Zohar contains the secret meaning of the Torah and its teachings for the Kabbalists alone, while the Talmud and the codes belong to the “revealed Torah” binding upon all devout Jews, whether or not they are Kabbalists. The followers of the Haskalah movement [the Jewish Enlightenment], on the other hand, denigrated the Zohar and the Kabbalah in general as a foreign shoot implanted into Judaism to encourage superstition and the irrational in religion. There are echoes of this conflict in Yemen, where followers of the Darda movement [a Yemenite Haskalah movement] rejected the Zohar as a sacred work.
Did you like this article? MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.