Praying for the State of Israel

I’m a few days late, but I must take serious issue with my good friend Ariel Beery’s recent Blogs of Zion post about the prayer for the State of Israel — and some communities that are revisiting its language and place in the service.

In a move that should shock no-one who understands the history of reform Judaism and its paradigm shift away from Judaism-as-a-lifestyle, the JTA is reporting that congregations have decided to stop or change their recitation of the Prayer for the Welfare of the State of Israel.

So wasn’t I surprised when the JTA article begins with a discussion of Altshul, the traditional egalitarian (reform?) minyan in Park Slope, Brooklyn that I have been involved with since its inception.

Ariel seems to see all those communities mentioned in the article as distinctly “religiousâ€? or “spiritualâ€? — i.e. unconcerned with Jewish Peoplehood. Writes Ariel: “From a Zionist perspective, this move is further proof that a Judaism that is limited to the religious tradition of the Jews acts to tear apart our historical community.â€?

As a loyal member of Altshul, I have to say that Ariel is seriously mistaken in his diagnosis of who we are. Altshul does, indeed, hold a prayer service, but I’d venture to say that more of its members come for a sense of community and connection to other Jews than they do to commune with the Divine Spirit.

(In fact, I’ve described Altshul – in jest – as Hadar without soul.)

Ariel concludes his post with a bewildering statement that I’d love for him to explain:

In this case, the unwillingness of American Jewish ’spiritual folk’ to get their hands dirty suggests, I would argue, that they’re leaving us behind — that is, the Jewish People — in their own search for purity. But since they haven’t yet accepted the principal of conversion, they’re less like the early Christians and more like the Essenes — and if history is any indication, I’m not sure it’ll turn out so well for them either.

What principal of conversion have the “spiritual folk� (we Altshulers?) not accepted?

For the record, Altshul — as far as I know — continues to recite the prayer for the State of Israel.

Discover More

Praying Differently & Together

As promised, here is the complete text of Sarah Margles’ speech about the Prayer for the State of Israel (mentioned ...

Jewcy: The Early Reviews

Jewish bloggers have written their first reviews of the recently launched and they’re not being generous.– Ariel over at ...

Praying for Israel, Part III

Over the last few days, I’ve written much (I, II, III) about the Prayer for the State of Israel and ...