Jewcy: The Early Reviews

By | Tagged: General

Jewish bloggers have written their first reviews of the recently launched and they’re not being generous.

– Ariel over at Blogs of Zion writes:

The artwork is amazing — the content, well, not so much…I don’t really care whether Jews are at the top of the evangelical movement, or what a porn-star’s mother says about her choice of a career. Moreover, I don’t see why answering the question as to why Israeli’s are pricks is “what matters now” as the Jewcy tagline claims.

Steven I. Weiss from Canonist is even harsher:

The press release, and the site, announce a slogan of “What matters now.� Well, not Jewcy, that’s for sure.
Sure, there are the items you’d expect, from the blatantly ignorant, the blogs that seem more masturbatory than informative, and the first person pieces that laboriously detail the lives of people you couldn’t care less about.
And the stuff by writers from whom you’ve learn to expect good things feel like toss-offs. Lauren Grodstein’s got a relatively interesting story about how Jews are perceived…from 1998. Somehow, even Neal Pollack’s stuff isn’t all that great there.

Jewlicious, commenting on an earlier Jewcy beta site, opined:

In the meantime, in terms of content, Jewcy looks like it’s going to provide much of the same old same old.

And on the comment board at Jewlicious, Jewschool’s Mobius chimed in:

eh, i saw the beta a while ago. i’m not impressed. in fact, i’m so unimpressed that i don’t even consider it a threat.

they say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. if people are biting you, it means you’re a step ahead of them. jewcy may have a budget that i don’t, but they don’t have any original ideas (and they also clearly have no design sense or technical know-how), which means they’re destined for failure. which is sad because… what a waste of money i could’ve put to better use.

And then tempered his response with another comment:

Posted on November 20, 2006

Note: The opinions expressed here are the personal views of the author. All comments on are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed. Privacy Policy