Mourning and the Right to Lead Davening

This entry was posted in General on by .

(Cross posted at Blog the Kaddish)

Some of the rules of being a mourner seem obvious to me.  I understand why I’m prohibited from going to see a live music or theater performance, and I appreciate that restriction.  It makes sense to hold back from such public displays of jubilation and drama when I’m still, internally, an emotion basket case.  It also seems like a sign of respect to my mother that in the wake of her death I refrain from going to big shows and concerts.

But when I first heard that mourners had a greater hiyuv, or obligation, to daven, than other people attending a minyan, and were thus the preferred choice for leading services, I was surprised.  It’s one thing to require that we show up every day and praise God despite the raw grief we’re feeling, but it’s another thing entirely to say that we should lead others in long expressions of thanks every morning, afternoon and night.  That seems almost perverse.  Of course I can go through the motions, but should I–or any mourner–really be leading davening when they’re likely having a crisis of faith, or at the very least struggling with loss and acceptance?

That’s what I used to think, but I’ve changed my mind.

Some days I feel like I am in a constant one-sided conversation with God.  That whole bargaining stage of grieving? It’s for real, people.  So it makes sense that I’d be the person to lead the plea for his goodwill.  But also, and perhaps more importantly, when you’re a shaliach tzibur, you have to pay close attention to what’s going on.  You have to be more present in the moment than if you’re just answering Amen to someone reciting a blessing at the front of the room.  Grieving can feel like being very far away from the world, and from everything that’s happening in it.  Standing at the amud calling out words of joy and gratitude to God–it requires you to focus yourself, and it focuses others on your words.  You can’t be far away.

I didn’t think I would feel this way, but especially in the past couple of weeks I’ve been itching to lead davening.  I have a few things to say to God.  I can’t wait to stand at the Amud.

Posted on October 27, 2008

Note: The opinions expressed here are the personal views of the author. All comments on MyJewishLearning are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed. Privacy Policy

2 thoughts on “Mourning and the Right to Lead Davening

  1. DOVID

    Interesting. My experience has been the opposite. I have a difficult time focussing on my davening when I’m in front of the tzibur, as I am a slow davener. You can sense the anxiety growing as more and more people finish before I do. Then they are accustomed to a quick repetition, which I am simply not adept at doing. IMHO, the PRIORITY in davening under ANY circumstances is KAVANAH. So, for a mourner who cannot focus well when daving in front of the tzibor, it is bigger zchus for the neshamah of the deceased to NOT daven before the tzibur; let someone else do so, and daven with kavanah to Hashem. What zchus can there be for your lost relative in davening without kavanah? Your opinoion woulod be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

  2. Tamar Fox Post author

    I don’t think you should lead davening if it’s not something you’re generally comfortable with. If being the leader will lead you to have less kavanah then it may not be right for you. I was just expressing how I felt, and how it surprised me.

Comments are closed.

Privacy Policy