Fried gefilte fish | Photo credit: Chaya Rappoport
Prep Cook Yield Ready In
5 minutes 15 minutes 4 20 minutes

We Should All Be Frying Our Gefilte Fish

A little oil is all it takes to transform this Ashkenazi staple.

If fish were in a popularity contest, herring would win most interesting, anchovies would win funkiest, and salmon would win classiest. Gefilte fish wouldn’t even place.

All this is to say: If you happen to find yourself staring down a jar of the Ashkenazi staple that is lumpy, gray whitefish quenelles and decide to pass, well, I wouldn’t blame you. 

This Hanukkah, I thought it was high time gefilte fish underwent a makeover — and turns out, all it needed was a little oil. Freed from the confines of long oval slices, when shaped into balls and flash fried, gefilte fish morphs from bland and watery to crunchy, golden, and puffy — more akin to an irresistible tater tot than to the loathed loaves of my youth.

So, to turn gefilte fish from a boring side to a chic hors d’oeuvre, put down the over-boiled carrots and the jarred stuff. Instead, fry your gefilte fish and serve with aioli (I love the Swiss Thomy brand — it’s the silkiest mayonnaise you’ll ever taste!), then top with paprika, fresh dill, and salty caviar. 

It may not be a jar of oil that lasted for eight days, but it’s gefilte fish you’ll actually want to eat. And that’s a Hanukkah miracle of its own. 

Photo credit: Chaya Rappoport


  • 1 loaf gefilte fish, defrosted (I like Raskin’s, which is sold in most kosher groceries)
  • vegetable oil, for frying 
  • fine sea salt
  • mayonnaise, paprika, chopped fresh dill, and caviar, for serving 


  1. Roll the defrosted loaf of gefilte fish into small balls, around the size of golf balls.
  2. Heat 1” oil in a nonstick frying pan and gently drop the balls into the oil. They’ll begin to bubble and, once golden brown, use a fork or spatula to flip them to brown on the other side. 
  3. Remove the fried gefilte fish balls to a paper towel-lined plate. Sprinkle with fine sea salt while still hot. 
  4. Serve with mayo on the side and a dusting of paprika, sprinkle of dill, and dab of caviar.

Keep on Noshing

Trader Joe’s Cauliflower Latkes Are Actually Legit

These cheesy, carb-free latkes might be our new holiday favorite.

Japanese-Style Latkes for Hanukkah

These traditional pancakes are the perfect way to shake things up for the holiday.

Why Do We Eat Jelly Donuts on Hanukkah?

The answer has everything to do with agriculture, food politics and -- of course -- tastebuds.