Saturday, October 27, 2018, marked the deadliest attack on Jews in American history. That morning, a gunman entered Pittsburgh’s Tree of Life-Or L’Simcha Congregation during Shabbat services, killing 11 Jewish worshippers and injuring several others. The massacre prompted many American Jews to question their safety in a country where their families had sought refuge.
Tree of Life, which at the time housed three congregations (Tree of Life-Or L’Simcha, New Light Congregation, and Dor Hadash), is located in Pittsburgh’s heavily Jewish neighborhood of Squirrel Hill. The attack left the American Jewish community in and beyond Pittsburgh reeling. In the immediate aftermath, Pittsburgh’s largest-circulation newspaper, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, printed the Jewish memorial prayer, the Mourner’s Kaddish, in Hebrew letters atop its front page. In the years that followed, the tragedy was the subject of museum exhibits and books, and it was even referenced in a popular TV show.
A Tragic Day
The victims killed in Tree of Life shooting were longtime congregants: brothers Cecil Rosenthal, 59, and David Rosenthal, 54, who lived in a residential home for people with disabilities and were active members of the local Jewish community; Bernice Simon, 84, and Sylvan Simon, 86, a couple who were married at the Tree of Life Synagogue in 1956; Daniel Stein, 71, a former president of the New Light Congregation; physician Jerry Rabinowitz, 66, who had served as president of the Reconstructionist synagogue Dor Hadash; Richard Gottfried, 65, a dentist and member of New Light Congregation; Joyce Fienberg, 75, a retired university researcher; Rose Mallinger, a retired school secretary and, at age 97, the shooting’s oldest victim; Melvin Wax, 88, a retired accountant who was leading services at the time of the attack; and Irving Younger, 69, a father and grandfather.
On the morning of the shooting, the gunman, Robert Bowers, writing on a far-right social media platform, took aim at the Jewish-founded refugee resettlement organization HIAS, formerly the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society. He blamed HIAS for bringing “invaders in that kill our people,” before saying he was “going in,” apparently referring to the synagogue. HIAS, which has long supported immigrants in America — including successive waves of Jews fleeing antisemitic violence — has also been a frequent target of conspiracy theories.
Curious Minds Welcome. Whatever you're wondering about Judaism, My Jewish Learning has an answer, and it's free because readers like you make it so. Give to open more doors for Jewish discovery.
In 2023, Bowers was found guilty on 63 counts and was sentenced to death. Before leaving office in 2024, President Joe Biden commuted the death sentences of 37 out of the 40 federal prisoners on death row; Bowers was not one of them.
Bowers apparently believed in the white-nationalist “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory that imagines a Jewish plot to replace white Westerners with people of color from abroad. This debunked theory was also the motive behind a number of subsequent attacks, including an April 2019 shooting at a Poway, California, synagogue that killed one person and injured three others. That attack at a Chabad congregation took place six months to the day after the Tree of Life massacre. Great Replacement was also linked to two other deadly mass shootings committed just hours apart — one at an El Paso, Texas, Walmart, and another outside a bar in Dayton, Ohio; the gunman in the latter attack had reportedly shown a video of the Pittsburgh shooting to an ex-girlfriend on their first date.
The Aftermath
Following the attack on Tree of Life, Jewish communal institutions redoubled efforts to secure their spaces and congregants. Synagogues offered emergency trainings and hired additional security personnel. In 2019, the federal Nonprofit Security Grant Program was awarded $60 million to provide security for nonprofits, religious day schools and houses of worship. By September 2026, the Federal Emergency Management Agency, or FEMA, announced $300 million in grants to secure more than 1,600 nonprofits. Many Jewish institutions worked with the Jewish Federations of North America’s security arm, the Secure Communities Network, to apply for these grants.
Three years after the Tree of Life shooting, an armed man who had entered a Colleyville, Texas, synagogue and accepted a cup of tea from the rabbi took that same rabbi and three others hostage. Hours later, the rabbi ended the hostage standoff by throwing a chair at the gunman and encouraging everyone to run for the exit. He later credited the security training he received following the Pittsburgh massacre with saving lives that day. Similarly, a 2026 car-ramming attack and attempted shooting in a Detroit, Michigan, suburb was thwarted by an armed security team that had recently undergone crisis training.
A Shift in American Jewish Life
The Pittsburgh synagogue shooting ultimately tested American Jews’ sense of belonging in a nation that many had considered a safe haven. The late journalist Howard Fineman, a former Tree of Life congregant, wrote at the time that “the mass murder at Tree of Life has shaken my perhaps naïve faith in this country.”
A year after the Tree of Life shooting, a survey of American Jews reflected rising fears of antisemitism, with one in three respondents saying that they had hidden or avoided wearing symbols of their faith, like kippahs and Star of David jewelry, and one in four reporting that they sometimes avoid places and situations for fear of being targeted.
Increasingly, Jewish life was beginning to resemble that of Europe, where antisemitic hate was long considered a fact of life, reflected David Harris, the former CEO of the American Jewish Committee, which conducted the study. “Perhaps there was a time when some Jewish institutions … felt somehow more or less insulated from [anti-Semitic attacks],” told The Washington Post. “The fact that the attacks took place in Pittsburgh and Poway triggered a feeling that we’re all at risk everywhere, equally — it can happen anywhere.”
The Tree of Life building was mostly demolished in 2024, and, as of 2026, construction was underway on a new synagogue campus that will house the Tree of Life-Or L’Simcha Congregation. It will also include programming spaces and a museum that tells the story of the shooting that changed Pittsburgh and shook the larger American Jewish community.