Bekhorot 42

Doubtful blemishes.

Bekhorot 42
Advertisement
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

The first 11 mishnahs of chapter six in Tractate Bekhorot detail the many blemishes that render an animal exempt from the sacrificial requirements of a bekhor, with the result that the priest may slaughter and eat the animal anywhere he chooses. The chapter’s concluding mishnah, introduced on yesterday’s daf, shifts focus to blemishes of uncertain status. Having one of these doubtful blemishes means the animal ends up stuck in a state of limbo: It can’t be slaughtered as part of the bekhorot ritual, nor can it be eaten or sold by the priest outside of the Temple. Doubtful blemishes include things like pale spots in the eye and warts, as well as general poor health or unpleasant smell.

Mishnah 12 closes its list of unresolved blemishes with animals that are either tumtum, possessing hidden or unidentifiable sexual organs, or androgynos, possessing characteristics of both male and female external sexual organs:

And one does not slaughter a tumtum or an androgynos, neither in the Temple nor in the rest of the country. 

Rabbi Shimon says: You have no blemish greater than that (and it may be slaughtered). 

Curious Minds Welcome. Whatever you're wondering about Judaism, My Jewish Learning has an answer, and it's free because readers like you make it so. Give to open more doors for Jewish discovery.

Choose an amount to donate

The rabbis say: The halakhic status of an androgynos is not that of a firstborn; rather, its halakhic status is that of a non-sacred animal that may be shorn and utilized for labor.

The mishnah records three opinions about what to do with the animal with unusual sex characteristics. According to the anonymous first opinion, the animal is treated like the other cases of unresolved blemishes in the mishnah: It stays in limbo, neither offered as a bekhor, nor redeemed and eaten as an indisputably blemished animal. Rabbi Shimon, on the other hand, says these animals should be treated like any other bekhor with definite blemishes. And finally, according to the sages, the animal is not a bekhor at all, but rather a category unto itself.  Since it is not male, possession of the animal remains with the original owner of the flock.

This is not a purely intellectual exercise, but one with significant economic import. If the first opinion is followed, both the original owner and the priest lose out on the animal’s value. If Rabbi Shimon’s view holds sway, the priest acquires unrestricted benefit from the animal. If the sages are followed, the original owner gets her animal back to use as she pleases, without any restrictions.

In interpreting our mishnah, the Gemara unpacks the broader implications of these three tannaitic views of a firstborn animal of indeterminate sex classification. Rav Hisda then moves to limit the argument between them to only the androgynos:

Rav Hisda says: This dispute applies to an androgynos, which the rabbis maintain is a distinct entity, as it has both male and female sex organs, and therefore it does not have firstborn status. But with regard to a tumtum, whose genitalia is covered by skin, everyone agrees that it is an uncertain case, as it is definitely either a male or a female, but there is uncertainty as to which it is. Consequently, it is consecrated due to uncertainty, and it may not be slaughtered either in the Temple or in the rest of the country.

Rav Hisda maintains there is broad agreement about what is to be done with a firstborn tumtum (it has bekhor status), and the disagreement is only over the firstborn androgynos.

In the discussion that ensues, several other halakhic cases are introduced where a lack of clarity around the sex classification of a person or an animal causes confusion with financial and legal repercussions on the people and objects that engage with them. For example: What happens if an intersex person promises their value (the subject matter of Tractate Arakhin) to the Temple? Do we use the financial formulas the rabbis set up for men or women in determining what they owe to pay off their pledge?  Another example: Do intersex individuals perform the rituals of levirate marriage if a male sibling dies without fathering children? And if they were married to a woman, would their brother perform levirate marriage if they died childless?

The Gemara is analytical about these cases, which might surprise us. Seen broadly, the Talmud is a literary corpus that obsessively works to fit almost everything into binary categories: kosher/not kosher, permitted/forbidden, married/divorced, sacred/mundane and so forth.  When it comes to these binary-defying sex traits, the text evinces neither fear nor discomfort, simply curiosity. Further, it is not prurient curiosity, but legal curiosity.

In its formal, legalistic way, the Talmud models a matter-of-fact way of dealing with what could have become — and in our era, has become — a heated, degrading or sensationalized conversation about sexual difference. Reading this page of Talmud left me searching for new-old ways to consider complicated social and political dilemmas.  How can we listen patiently and calmly across differences? How can we argue — vehemently even — about legal consequences, without giving in to fear, contempt or mockery?

Read all of Bekhorot 42 on Sefaria.

This piece originally appeared in a My Jewish Learning Daf Yomi email newsletter sent on October 30, 2026. If you are interested in receiving the newsletter, sign up here.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Discover More

Bekhorot 48

When heirs come in pairs.

Bekhorot 46

Protection over precision.

Advertisement