Bekhorot 41

Impermanent blemishes.

Bekhorot 41
Advertisement
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Imagine you are a priest in the land of Israel in the second century. The Temple is no longer standing. Your neighbor has brought you their firstborn animal, and you must now care for the animal and wait for it to develop a blemish so that you can slaughter and eat it. You must be sure not to blemish the animal yourself, and you should watch carefully for any developments on the animal’s body.
 
This chapter of Bekhorot provides many examples of blemishes that will allow you to slaughter the firstborn. These blemishes, on the whole, must be visible and permanent.
 
The final mishnah of the chapter, which appears on today’s daf, enumerates conditions that render the animal unfit for sacrifice in the Temple, but are impermanent — meaning the animal cannot be slaughtered yet. If your animal has one of these blemishes, then you, as the priestly recipient of this firstborn, must wait for the condition to go away and for a permanent blemish to appear before you can slaughter the animal and eat it. Here is that list of impermanent blemishes:

And these are the blemishes on account of which one does not slaughter a firstborn, neither in the Temple nor in the rest of the country: Pale spots on the eye and tears streaming from the eye that are not constant; and internal gums that were damaged but were not extracted; an animal with skin disease; an animal with warts; an animal with boils; and an old or sick animal, or one with a foul odor.

In addition to various kinds of impermanent blemishes, the mishnah states that an animal that is old, sick, or has a foul odor is likewise unfit for sacrifice, but cannot be slaughtered and eaten. The Gemara immediately steps in to question how the mishnah knows that these three conditions continue to suspend the animal in the “wait and see” category.

From where are these matters derived? They are derived from a verse, as the sages taught: The verse states: “And if his offering be from the flock, whether from the sheep or from the goats” (Leviticus 1:10). These three instances of the word “from” serve to exclude the old, the sick and the animal with a foul odor, which may not be sacrificed.

At first glance, the inclusion of the word “from” three times in this verse from Leviticus seems incidental, but the Talmud finds it ripe for interpretation, deriving that (1) old, (2) sick and (3) smelly animals are not fit for slaughter in the Temple.
 
In the next stage of the discussion, the Talmud questions whether the Leviticus verse really needed to use the word “from” three times. Why wouldn’t it have been sufficient to use the word once and derive all three conditions from that one usage?
 
The answer is that had the verse used “from” only once, we could have erroneously concluded that only an old animal, which will never get younger, is unfit for sacrifice, but a sick or malodorous animal, which may eventually become healthy or fresh-smelling, is fit for sacrifice. Alternatively, one might have thought that one use of “from” would have excluded an animal that is sick, but not one that is old. And had “from” been used twice, instead of three times, one might have thought that the usage excludes weak animals from eligibility for slaughter, but not an animal that reeks but is otherwise in good health.
 
In the end, three instances of “from” turn out to be the perfect amount to derive this law, and everything is accounted for. The Talmud has provided biblical justification for the inclusion of these three conditions in our list of the types of temporary blemishes that are disqualifying for slaughter in the Temple, but not permanent enough to allow the priest to slaughter it quite yet.
 
So if you, the priest in our hypothetical from earlier, have a firstborn in your possession who is old, sick or rank, you’re just going to have to wait a little bit longer before eating it.

Read all of Bekhorot 41 on Sefaria.

This piece originally appeared in a My Jewish Learning Daf Yomi email newsletter sent on October 29, 2026. If you are interested in receiving the newsletter, sign up here.

Curious Minds Welcome. Whatever you're wondering about Judaism, My Jewish Learning has an answer, and it's free because readers like you make it so. Give to open more doors for Jewish discovery.

Choose an amount to donate
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Discover More

Bekhorot 48

When heirs come in pairs.

Bekhorot 46

Protection over precision.

Advertisement