Bekhorot 39

Concealed blemishes.

Bekhorot 39
Advertisement
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

After spending much of this tractate discussing how blemishes disqualify a bekhor (firstborn), we are now finally discussing what exactly these blemishes look like. Having looked at eye blemishes yesterday, a mishnah on today’s daf turns to damaged or missing teeth (or, depending on which commentator you follow, gums):

If the outer incisors are defective or leveled to the gum, or the molars are torn out, these are disqualifying blemishes. But Rabbi Hanina ben Antigonus says: We do not examine behind the molars, nor the molars themselves.

The important distinction here is which teeth are readily visible. While there is a difference of opinion about where the line is drawn, the general agreement is that significant damage to visible teeth is considered a blemish while damage to teeth farther back in the mouth is not disqualifying. The mishnah uses the language of “internal” (invisible) and “external” (visible) teeth.

This prompts a much broader halakhic question in the Gemara:

Rav Ahadvoi bar Ami raises a dilemma: Is there halakhic significance to the lack of a limb that is internal, or is there no halakhic significance to the lack of a limb that is internal?

The discussion of teeth, especially those further back in the mouth, opens the door to a discussion of blemishes that are invisible. Rav Ahadvoi inquires whether the lacking an “internal” limb — that is, a missing internal organ — is halakhically significant in the same way as lacking an “external” limb. The Gemara proceeds to inquire what exactly he means by “halakhically significant”:

With regard to what issue? If it was with regard to whether such a blemish renders permitted the slaughter of a firstborn outside the Temple, it is written: “Lameness or blindness” (Deuteronomy 15:21). If the dilemma was raised with regard to whether other sacrificial animals with such a blemish are thereby disqualified from being sacrificed and may be redeemed, it is written: “Blind or broken” (Leviticus 22:22). 

There are two possible ways a blemish might affect the legal status of a bekhor. A significant blemish would prevent the bekhor from being sacrificed and render it redeemable, ultimately allowing the priest to eat it. A less significant blemish, however, might in theory prevent the bekhor from being offered on the altar but allow the animal to retain enough sanctity that it also cannot be redeemed and consumed as ordinary meat by the priest.

The paradigmatic blemishes the Torah lists are external ones, so the Gemara assumes that blemishes significant enough to permit redemption and slaughter must also be external ones. Therefore, Rav Ahadvoi must be asking about the other case: minor blemishes that also preclude redemption. Do these “internal” missing organs fall into that category?

We do not raise this dilemma with regard to slaughtering the firstborn or redeeming other sacrificial animals. Rather, we raise the dilemma with regard to disqualifying the animal from sacrifice. What is the halakhah?

The Merciful One states:
“It shall be complete (tamim) to be accepted” (Leviticus 22:21), which indicates that a complete animal, yes, is fit as a sacrifice, but if it is lacking in any manner, it is not fit. Or perhaps one should interpret the phrase, “It shall be complete to be accepted,” in light of what is stated immediately afterward: “There shall be no blemish therein.” Just as a blemish is on the outside, so too, the status of lacking a limb applies only if it is lacking on the outside.

For an animal to be suited for sacrifice, the verse says it must be tamim — complete, or perfect. This is Rav Ahadvoi’s question: Does the word tamim indicate a higher standard than simply lacking a standard blemish? Does any deficit — including lack of an internal organ — disqualify an animal from sacrifice? Or is the word tamim just another way of saying “not blemished,” and therefore anything that doesn’t constitute a blemish — such a missing internal organ — would also not disqualify an animal from sacrifice?

The Gemara takes a winding path through several attempted proofs to answer this question. Ultimately, the majority opinion is that a missing internal organ, while not a blemish, indeed disqualifies an animal from sacrifice.

This is a great example of a scenario in which we can’t neatly apply the same legal metric across similar but non-identical cases. I might have thought that the standards for any form of disqualification are the same. This sugya teaches us that there’s a middle ground: An animal can be too imperfect to be offered as a sacrifice, yet not blemished enough to lose its sanctity and be redeemed.

Read all of Bekhorot 39 on Sefaria.

This piece originally appeared in a My Jewish Learning Daf Yomi email newsletter sent on October 27, 2026. If you are interested in receiving the newsletter, sign up here.

Curious Minds Welcome. Whatever you're wondering about Judaism, My Jewish Learning has an answer, and it's free because readers like you make it so. Give to open more doors for Jewish discovery.

Choose an amount to donate
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Discover More

Bekhorot 48

When heirs come in pairs.

Bekhorot 46

Protection over precision.

Advertisement