A Yom Kippur folk-custom
Among the more well-known but most controversial High Holiday customs is Kaparot, which usually involves swinging a chicken over one's head as a form of penance. Although, as this article shows, the custom was opposed by many Jewish sages, it is still practiced today in many traditionalist communities. This article is excerpted with permission from Entering the High Holy Days. Reprinted with permission from the Jewish Publication Society.
Over the centuries, many customs have sprung up to enhance the way in which we enter Yom Kippur, the final day of this season. Some of these customs, such as flogging oneself to atone for sin, happily have been forgotten. Others, such as immersion in a mikvah to indicate a state of purity, are still practiced by some. The most well‑known and yet most controversial of these customs is the practice of Kaparot, which literally means "atonements," but in the sense of "ransom."
Traditionally, a rooster is swung around one's head and is then slaughtered while being declared a "substitute" for the individual, as an atonement for his or her sins. Like the Tashlikh ceremony of Rosh Hashanah, Kaparot is a folk ceremony that may have had superstitious, pagan origins. Rabbinic opposition to Kaparot has been strong and remains so today.
Some lived in deepest darkness, bound in cruel irons ... (Ps. 107:10).
He brought them out of deepest darkness, broke their bonds asunder ... (107:14).
There were fools who suffered for their sinful way, and for their iniquities. All food was loathsome to them: They reached the gates of death. In their adversity they cried to the Lord and He saved them from their troubles. He gave an order and healed them; He delivered them from the pits. Let them praise the Lord for His steadfast love, His wondrous deeds for mankind (107:17‑21).
These verses are followed by an additional excerpt from the Book of Job:
Then He has mercy on him and decreed, "Redeem him from descending to the Pit, For I have obtained his ransom" (33:24).
To this is added the words: Life for life.
Prayers are then recited, indicating the function of the rooster as a substitute for the individual. The rooster is twirled three times around the head of each man; a hen is used for women. Both birds are then slaughtered and given to the poor. Some people have substituted money, in this ceremony, for the rooster or hen.
One need not go as far as those scholars who see the Kaparot as originating in an offering to Satan in order to understand the many objections to this ritual. Kaparot follows the pattern of the scapegoat, a ritual of riddance, but comes too close to superstition in indicating that one may substitute the death of an animal for one's own life. Among those who objected to the ceremony were the 13th‑century Moses ben Nahman (the Ramban) and the 16th‑century Rabbi Joseph Karo, who wrote in his great work the Shulchan Arukh: "The custom of Kaparot ... is a practice that ought to be prevented." Needless to say, the objections of great authorities were not sufficient to prevent this ritual from becoming an accepted custom among the people.
Did you like this article? MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.