I am a champion whiner, but even I have to admit that there comes a time when we each need to stop feeling sorry for ourselves, stop complaining, and get back to the business of living. I often find myself looking forward to that point in the midst of a crisis. Yes, thereâ€™s some appeal to wallowing in oneâ€™s sorrow, and allowing oneself to maintain a certain sense of misery when bad times seem to be the rule, and not the exception, but I find that I hit my threshold after about twelve hours, and then, ideally, I would like to go on to some task that I can focus on instead of my own shitty situation.
This year has afforded me many more opportunities to wallow than Iâ€™m really comfortable with. It seems that every week or two there is some enormous issue that saps 90% of my mental energy, and gives me another reason to feel sorry for myself. My grandmother died a few weeks ago, shortly before that my sisters and I found out some news that upset us. Since then weâ€™ve celebrated Pesach without my mother, and found out about a number of deaths and illnesses in our community, as well as upcoming simchas among our community and friends. Even good things are still tinged with this sense of strangeness, a foreign and empty feeling Iâ€™ve come to know as I go through life constantly thinking about how my mother would have reacted to a piece of news or a major historical event.
Itâ€™s not difficult to imagine what my mother would have said about most of these things. I knew her very well, of course, but these have tended to be events to which there isnâ€™t likely to be a variety of responses. She would have been sad to hear that some of our friends are sick, and would have mourned my grandmother’s death. She would have grinned and hugged those who are engaged, married and expecting babies. But knowing what she would have thought and said is no consolation at all. The reason we have friends and the reason we cling to our families is not to hear the words we all expect at happy and sad occasions, itâ€™s to feel, somehow, that both joy and pain are being shared by those we love. We want to see our own feelings mirrored in others because it lightens our load when weâ€™re downtrodden, and increases our joy when weâ€™re happy. When my mother died, I lost perhaps the biggest and most important mirror in my life. She was the person that so many of us went to when we wanted sympathy, pride, love, acceptance and even grief reflected back at us. And like all good mirrors, though she most often reflected back what you already knew or thought, she was unafraid to tell people when they were being unreasonable, and needed to shape up.
I think about this idea often as I say Kaddish at minyan, because I am not at all sure how my mother would have reacted to my frustrations and the theological confusion I now feel about saying this mourning prayer. I remember one or two conversations we had about her own experiences saying Kaddish for her father, but I was 14 at the time, and didnâ€™t have any concept of what the experience would be like for an adult. I still donâ€™t think I have a concept of what itâ€™s like to say Kaddish when youâ€™re in your forties and fifties. So I donâ€™t know what she would have said if I would have told her that I find myself resenting going to shul, bored and angry during most services. Would she have shared my frustrations, or would she have reminded me of the history and significance of the Kaddish through centuries of Jewish life, and of her own commitment when her father died? I can see either. Or actually, neither.
I feel sorry for myself, again.
[The photo is of me and my mom when I was about eight years old. I chose it because I think we look so much like each otherâ€”mirror images, if you will.]
Cross-posted at Blogging the Kaddish.