Overview: Women in Traditional Jewish Sources

Print this page Print this page

woman in the subIn rabbinic law, women have fewer religious responsibilities than men. As a general rule, they are exempt from positive time-bound commandments, such as fixed prayer at particular times of the day. According to scholar Judith Hauptman, this ruling also reflects female subordination. If a woman were compelled to fulfill time-bound commandments, this, "would lessen her husband's dominance over her because she would have to cease temporarily from serving him, and instead serve God."

Attitudes toward women in the Middle Ages built on rabbinic models, but also reflected the general cultural milieu of individual Jewish communities. In sources originating in Muslim lands, we often find more restrictive attitudes toward women. According to Maimonides, "There is nothing more beautiful for a wife than sitting in the corner of her house." In addition, Maimonides allowed a husband to beat his wife if she consistently refused to fulfill wifely duties such as washing his hands and feet.

An example of the discrepancy between attitudes in Muslim and Christian lands can be seen in the response of Maimonides' critic Abraham ben David of Posquieres, a French authority, who noted that he had, "never heard that it is permitted to raise a rod against a woman."

In the medieval mystics' theology of sefirot, some of God's ten attributes are female. The sefirah known as Malkhut or Shekhinah is the primary female manifestation of God, and to a certain extent the existence of such a manifestation made femaleness praiseworthy. Still, the female attributes of God were considered secondary, subservient, and passive, receiving power from the primary male attributes.

As for "real" women, the mystics generally believed that their primary purpose was the facilitation of men's religious life. Thus a fascinating passage in the Zohar, the most important medieval mystical work, relates that the halls of the afterlife are presided over by women who gave birth to or aided great men. 

In the past 30 years, scores of teshuvot, or responsa (written rabbinic answers to specific legal questions) have been written about women's issues. The liberal denominations have addressed women's leadership of public prayer and the entrance of women into the rabbinate and cantorate, while Orthodox responsa have covered issues such as women's prayer groups and women's recitation of the mourner's kaddish. Many of these Orthodox responsa address not only the legality of such innovations, but also the social ramifications of change. One of the concerns reflected is that innovating tradition--even when it is permissible under Jewish law--could position the community on a "slippery slope," leading to practices which do conflict with Jewish law.

Did you like this article?  MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.

Please consider making a donation today.