Two Jewish Views on End of Life Issues
The Conservative movement validates two opinions on ceasing medical treatment for terminally ill patients.
The following is a summary issued by the Rabbinical Assembly, the association of Conservative rabbis, to summarize the Conservative movement's positions on end-of-life issues. In the Rabbinical Assembly's Committee on Jewish Law and Standards (CJLS)--which decides issues of halakhah (Jewish law)--multiple legal opinions on a single topic may be accepted if each receives a certain amount of support among committee members. This is the case described below: Rabbi Avram Israel Reisner's teshuvah (rabbinic responsum or ruling) is that life-saving treatments should be pursued except in cases where treatment serves only to prolong the dying process. Rabbi Elliot Dorff sees more latitude in Jewish law for terminally ill patients to refuse life-prolonging treatment when there is no hope for a cure. Reprinted with permission of the Rabbinical Assembly.
On Dec. 12, 1990, the CJLS debated two papers submitted by Rabbis Elliot Dorff and Avram Israel Reisner, members of the CJLS' sub-committee on biomedical ethics, on end-of-life issues. Both papers were adopted by the Committee, Rabbi Dorff's by a vote of 11-2-5, Rabbi Reisner's by a vote of 13-14 (members were given the option of voting for both papers). Thus both positions are valid views. The key points of each are summarized below.
However, the papers are very detailed and complex, and what follows cannot substitute for careful study of the authors' writings. Both papers, as well as two responses from other sub-committee members, appear in the Spring 1991 issue of Conservative Judaism.
The Rabbinical Assembly has also published a living will, entitled Advanced Medical Directives, which you can order from the United Synagogue Book Service, 800-594-5617, or download at: http://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/docs/medical%20directives.pdf.
Rabbi Dorff's Position
The key category for dealing with end-of-life issues is the terefah [a halakhic designation for someone who has an incurable disease but may life for an extended period].
a. When the patient has an irreversible, terminal illness, medications and other forms of therapy may be withheld or withdrawn. Artificial nutrition and hydration may be considered a sub-category of medication in such circumstances, and therefore may also be withheld or withdrawn.
b. The category of terefah may also be applied to the person in a permanent vegetative state, and it would be permissible to remove artificial nutrition and hydration.
c. Terminally ill persons may, if they choose, engage in any medical regimen which has the slightest chance of reversing their prognosis. So long as the intention is to find a cure, they may do so even if they thereby simultaneously increase the risk of hastening death.
Did you like this article? MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.