Samuel Belkin, president of Yeshiva University from 1943 to 1975, put the Orthodox position concisely when he averred that the Torah, as God’s law, must be scrupulously obeyed. Its truth and wisdom, the highest possible, are sufficient for all time. No more needs to be said. The authority of the Chooser, the uniqueness of the Chosen, and the content of the chosenness are all affirmed unequivocally.
Chosen For Unique Obligations
Still, while other Orthodox Jews, less responsive to the gentile world and Jewish doubt, saw no need to justify the doctrine of chosenness, Belkin took pains to defend it.
“Our entire concept of election, of distinctiveness and separation, is based upon the greater degree of responsibility which the Torah places upon each one of us…Those who have, therefore, stricken the ‘atah bahartanu‘–the avowal of the doctrine of ‘chosenness’ [recited in the festival Amidah prayer]‑‑from our prayer book, have denied the raison d’être of the Jewish people as revealed in the Torah, and misinterpreted the Torah concept of distinctiveness or ‘chosenness’ which has nothing to do with superiority of race. It is rather a greater dedication to the moral precepts of the Torah, and the endeavor to live a highly disciplined spiritual life, which is the Jewish essence of kedushah (holiness).”
Photo credit: Benjamin Stern
Belkin’s stress on the “moral” and “spiritual”‑-rather than on the ritual enforcement of “distinctiveness and separation”–seems well attuned to the objections to election which his defense sought to meet. While his rhetoric could be Reform, the content varies considerably from Reform’s “mission” or Kaplan’s “vocation” or the adherence to tradition carefully navigated by the Conservatives. The burden of chosenness is simply and precisely defined: obligation by and to the halakhah [Jewish law] which Jews received at Sinai.
One sees this clearly in the first major essay undertaken in America by the intellectual and spiritual guide of modern Orthodoxy, Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik (1903‑1992).
Did you like this article? MyJewishLearning is a not-for-profit organization.